Gabe Cicala is a Lititz native with 20+ years of local experience and a proven track record as a top-producing real estate professional. Over the last three years, he has completed 85+ career transactions and nearly $40M in closed volume across PA, NC, and SC. In 2025, Gabe closed 29 transactions totaling [...]

Gabe Cicala is a Lititz native with 20+ years of local experience and a proven track record as a top-producing real estate professional. Over the last three years, he has completed 85+ career transactions and nearly $40M in closed volume across PA, NC, and SC. In 2025, Gabe closed 29 transactions totaling $15.2M.

Before returning to his Pennsylvania roots, Gabe served as Director of Lake Norman Sales at Stone Realty Group, where he was recognized as Strongest Negotiator, Top 2 Producer, and a Stone Standard Excellence Award recipient. He maintains a perfect five-star rating across 40+ client reviews. Gabe understands the psychology of buyers and sellers, as well as the contracts inside and out, which makes him a master of negotiation. For example, he increased a seller’s initial offer from $1M to $1.13M and secured a home for a buyer 25% below list price and 18% below appraised value. Before residential sales, Gabe served as Director of Marketing for a boutique Orlando brokerage under a mentor ranked among the top 0.001% of agents nationally. He also managed construction projects throughout Pennsylvania, including the closeout of the $25M Rossmoyne Elementary School project. Gabe graduated summa cum laude from High Point University with a BBA, a concentration in entrepreneurship, and a minor in marketing.

Gabe serves buyers, sellers, and investors throughout Lancaster County and surrounding markets, including Lititz, Lancaster, Ephrata, Manheim, Mount Joy, Millersville, New Holland, Leola, and beyond. As a homeowner and real estate investor himself, Gabe understands both the financial and emotional sides of a transaction. His goal is to provide an unmatched quality of service, negotiate aggressively, and provide all the necessary resources to make your real estate goals a reality